Sen. Ron Johnson said Social Security should be shut down, calling it a “Ponzi scheme” during a Wednesday appearance on Fox Business. The Wisconsin Republican’s comments came hours before he was due to lead a Senate Budget Committee hearing on the program, which he says has been “grossly mismanaged.”
Johnson said there was “really no way to fix Social Security” and argued that people should hope to recover some of their contributions if the program is ended. The hearing was titled “Social Security: The Reality.”
The progressive advocacy group Social Security Works condemned the remarks. Its president, Nancy Altman, called Johnson’s position “a brazen effort, in broad daylight, to steal Americans’ earned benefits.” Altman cited an estimated net worth of $40 million for the senator and warned that ending the program would leave millions of seniors and people with disabilities at risk of homelessness and hunger.
Other policy experts disputed Johnson’s account of the program’s finances. Steven Nuñez, director of stratification economics at the Roosevelt Institute, said the projected shortfall reflects Social Security’s limited, separate funding source, actuarial forecasting errors and lawmakers’ failure to act. “There is no bankruptcy or collapse in the cards,” he wrote, arguing that Congress must legislate.
Matt Darling, an employment policy fellow at the Niskanen Center, said a worst-case outcome would be payment of about 80% of benefits, which he likened to Japan’s old-age program. Policy analyst Ned Resnikoff warned that the proposal could carry political costs, recalling that George W. Bush’s 2004 effort to privatize Social Security stalled after an initial burst of momentum. Johnson is up for reelection in 2028.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!