Redistributing wealth may be harder as the resources behind modern life become more constrained, argues writer Kurt Cobb. He says populist politicians will need to rethink how they deliver health, transportation and education, focusing on the outcomes people need rather than simply expanding existing systems.
Cobb traces the appeal of today’s populism to an older tradition that challenged monopolies and concentrated power, defended ordinary citizens and opposed tariffs that hurt farmers and consumers. Texas senator-elect James Talarico expressed that divide as one between the top and bottom of the income and wealth scale, Cobb writes. Traditional remedies include expanding affordable public services and taxing high earners more, while preserving or lowering taxes for middle- and lower-income households.
In the late 19th century, economic growth made redistribution less dependent on taking wealth from one group to benefit another: the overall economy was expanding. Cobb argues that the current outlook is different. He describes an emerging scarcity of energy, metals such as copper and rare earths, crops, water and the infrastructure built around them. Pandemic-era supply disruptions and the Ukraine-Russia and Iran wars have contributed to rising prices, he says, but longer-term pressures include climate change, underinvestment in mining, mounting difficulties for farmers and ranchers, water shortages and the rising cost of fossil-fuel production. He argues these trends will persist even if the wars end.
For health, Cobb says restoring Medicaid and Medicare cuts and reinstating Affordable Care Act insurance subsidies could help people pay for care, but could also intensify medical-cost inflation and competition for scarce resources. He calls for shifting the focus from illness treatment toward health, including prevention through real foods, drawing on Robert Lustig’s Metabolical. He says the approach would challenge the food industry.
Cobb applies a similar distinction between services and the things used to provide them to transportation and education. Rather than treating car ownership as the goal, he argues, policy should help people get from place to place economically and sustainably. Education, he says, should be judged by whether it prepares people to participate in civic life, commerce, aesthetic pursuits and recreation—not simply by credentials or facilities. He offers no comprehensive program, but calls for experiments that prioritize those outcomes over expanding current systems.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!