MEPs propose NGO funding limits despite finding no proven breaches
A European Parliament inquiry into NGO funding found no established financial misconduct or breach of rules, but its authors are proposing restrictions based on reputational risk and perceived political alignment. The 71-page report was shared with EUobserver ahead of its presentation in Parliament on Wednesday, 18 November.
The Scrutiny Working Group (SWG) said the information it received did not support “clear and definitive conclusions” about the regularity of expenditure. On advocacy, Dutch centre-right MEP Dirk Gotink and Italian conservative Carlo Fidanza said the evidence could not show whether EU-funded lobbying changed legislative outcomes or distorted decision-making. Nor could it reliably quantify funding specifically directed at lobbying EU institutions.
The report does not establish wrongdoing by NGOs or the European Commission. But Gotink has previously said the inquiry was not aimed at determining whether conduct was illegal, but whether it was “politically undesirable”. The report argues that a “persistent perception” of closeness between the Commission and funded NGOs raises questions about the separation of powers, invoking reputational risk, propriety and perceived conflicts of interest.
Its recommendations include five-year funding bans for organisations that lobby EU or national institutions, phasing out core operating support and requiring administrative ring-fencing. German Green MEP Daniel Freund called the inquiry “a purely ideological project” and said it was “an attack on freedom of expression”. He added: “Anyone who receives EU money is expected to shut up. Yet no wrongdoing has ever been proven against these organisations.”
The report does not identify whose perception is allegedly harmed. According to the article, it cites no survey and includes no interviews with NGOs or funding beneficiaries, despite presenting a perceived conflict of interest or insufficient institutional distance as a concern.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!